(i) There is a group of five girls.(ii) Kamini is second in height but younger than Rupa.(iii) Pooja

(i) There is a group of five girls.
(ii) Kamini is second in height but younger than Rupa.
(iii) Pooja is taller than Monika but younger in age.
(iv) Rupa and Monika are of the same age but Rupa is tallest between them.
(v) Neelam is taller than Pooja and elder Rupa. To answer the question "who is the youngest person in the group", which of the given statements is superfluous ?

A. Only (i)

B. Only (ii)

C. Only (v)

D. Either (i) or (iv)

E. None of these

Answer: A. Only (i)

We first find the sequence of height :
By (iii), we have : M < P.
By (v), we have : P < N.
Now, Rupa is tallest and Kamini is is second in height.
So, the sequence of heights is : M < P < N < K < R.
Now, we determine the age sequence :
By (ii), we have : K < R.
By (iii), we have : P < M.
By (iv), we have : R = M.
By (v), we have : R < N.
So, the sequence of ages is : N < R = M < K < P or N < R = M < P < K.

Clearly, only statement (i) is not necessary.
Hence, the answer is (a).

Posted in: Comparison Type Questions - Puzzle Test - Verbal Reasoning